This focus idea is explored through:
Contrasting student and scientific views
Student everyday experiences
Students interpret the world from their own point of reference as an observer on the surface of the Earth. This has consequences for their understandings of ideas that include objects on a very large and often unimaginable scale like the sun, Earth and moon system. Their ideas about observations of the moon are often creative and unique. Some more general views are expressed here.
These ideas are also related to the focus idea
Day and night.
Students hold a range of views used to explain the illumination of the moon:
- we can only see the moon at night
- the moon absorbs the sun’s light and then emits it
- the moon makes light
- the moon shines because it is bright compared to the darkness that surrounds it.
Many students believe that phases of the moon are caused by:
- the Earth’s shadow
- clouds covering part of the moon
- the amount of light reflected off the Earth onto the moon.
Research: Skamp (2004)
Scientific view
The Earth is one of several planets that orbit the sun, and the moon orbits the Earth. The Earth is essentially a sphere and the Sun is a nearby star which is an unimaginably large ball of gas that radiates light and heat as products of nuclear reactions.
The Moon orbits the Earth once every 28 days while the Earth orbits the sun once every 365 days:
The sun always illuminates half of the moon and we can see the moon because the light produced by the sun is reflected from the moon’s surface. The illuminated shape of the Moon that we see from the Earth appears to change continuously as the moon revolves around the Earth during its 28 day journey. This apparent change in the moon’s shape is a consequence of us seeing changing amounts of the illuminated surface.
The moon is mistakenly thought to be only visible at night but can be seen in the day time sky with some difficulty.
For more detail which may be helpful to students in modelling the Earth and moon system see the Digilearn links (below) and:
Critical teaching ideas
- The Earth and the moon are spheres and the sun is a star and produces light.
- The Earth, moon and sun are part of the solar system, with the sun at its centre.
- The sun is so close compared with other stars that it is the major source of almost all of the light we observe in the day as well as the light reflected by the moon.
- The moon does not produce its own light. It is visible because it reflects light from the sun which always illuminates half of the moon’s sphere. This can be observed sometimes in the daytime and sometimes at night.
- The moon appears to change shape over each month because we see different amounts of the illuminated surface of the moon at different times each month due to the relationship between the positions of the Earth, sun and moon at any particular time.
Explore the relationships between ideas about the Earth, moon and sun in the
Concept Development Maps: (Gravity, Solar System).
Students should be encouraged to make use of day time and night time observations of the moon. Students should then be guided to develop their own questions to research and explore. In this way the research is more directed and not simply a fact finding exercise.
Students’ preconceptions should be identified and then their understanding should be guided and developed through discussion and hands-on activities. Opportunities to make models and to manipulate the models to help students explain their ideas should be provided.
The manipulation of models also assists students to view the motion of the sun, Earth and the moon from a new perspective, as an observer of the whole system, as opposed to their usual perspective, as an observer on a very small region on the surface of the Earth.
Note: Diagrams like the one shown are numerous in text books, however they remain very challenging to interpret because they require two dimensional representations to be expanded by the student into three dimensions before they can be of use to them.
In the diagram above, the reader is asked to look down from the Earth’s North Pole to imagine the moon located in several positions as it moves in its circular orbit around the Earth. The accompanying images of the moon’s face next to key positions provides a view of what the face of the moon would appear like if the student was to imagine they were an observer located on the Earth’s surface and looking at the moon in the direction of the arrows.
For an animated representation see the simulation provided by Digilearn (below) or
Teaching activities
Promote reflection and clarification of existing ideas
Encourage students to draw their ideas of what the Earth and moon system looks like (this will bring out students’ existing ideas) and the associated student explanations can be used to explore student ideas of the motion of the Earth, moon and sun.
Discussion can be used to challenge the existing ideas held by students and to help them to reflect on their understanding. Students may need to construct a number of drawings if they are to consider the critical teaching ideas listed above.
The use of drawings as a process for eliciting and refining student ideas makes this pedagogical approach quite open-ended and responsive to students’ ideas.
Students to collect evidence/data for analysis
Students can make observations of the apparent shape of the moon and record how the moon looks throughout the month.
After they have collected this data they can then explore how their observations could be explained by making a model of the sun, the Earth and the moon and manipulating the model to replicate their observations (it may be helpful to use a strong torch to model the sun). Then they can role play the motion to demonstrate their understanding of the phases of the moon.
Students could explore indigenous interpretations of the motion of the sun, Earth and moon. A useful site for this is:
In order to promote reflection of ideas students could explore the ideas of early scientists and how they are similar or different from their own ideas.
Further resources
Science related interactive learning objects can be found on the
FUSE Teacher Resources page.
To access the interactive learning object below, teachers must login to FUSE and search by Learning Resource ID:
-
Earth Rotation: Sky Watch – Turn an animated model of the Earth to explore how rotation affects the view of objects in the sky. Use a camera on the Earth's surface to compare views of sunrise, sunset, the movement of the Moon and position of the stars.
Compare views from space with views from the Earth. Answer a series of questions by experimenting with the model. For example, work out the time of day from given views. This learning object is one in a series of four objects.
Learning Resource ID: 68GQQZ